I have mixed feelings about so-called Reality TV. American Idle (mis-spelling intentional) leaves me cold. For one thing, letting the audience decide this popularity contest means that the most talented never win. Come on… is Taylor Hicks really the best that season had to offer? Maybe Americans would vote for him on the show, but they won’t buy his albums! On a couple of the ‘contests’, the winner was smart enough to use the show to become successful. Kelly Clarkson was not the most talented on season 1, but she listened to the judges and her advisers (at least until recently) and worked hard enough to have a successful post-idol career. While I am not a fan of country music, and did not believe that Carrie Underwood was the most talented on her season, she had the drive and clear vision of what she wanted to be successful. But those two have proven to be the exception, and not the rule.
Reality shows that put people in abnormal circumstances, like Survivor, Big Brother and their clones are not interesting to me at all. I have developed a fondness for The Amazing Race. I think the situations there are just close enough to real life that we can identify with the racers. I really prefer the reality shows that are more like documentaries, where the cameras follow people in their normal environment. The best example of this is “Deadliest Catch”. For three seasons Discovery Channel cameramen followed Alaskan King crab fishermen while they fished for crab in the Bearing Sea, in Winter!! Pretty riveting stuff. I also loved Meerkat Manor on the Animal Planet channel. But with the big changes in the Whiskers mob (the dominant family group), and the untimely death of matriarch Flower, I don’t think it will be back this year.
And then there are the contest shows. Not the popularity type with the viewers voting, but where there are a panel of judges. Bravo TV seems to have the best of these. Starting with my current favorite;
. In this show, a group of contestants who work in the fashion industry (not people off the street) compete weekly in a series of challenges that are then judged by a panel of fashion experts. The show is produced and hosted by model Heidi Klum. Eventually, the field of contestants is narrowed down to three who then design a line of clothing that is shown in New York at Fashion Week. Since the New York fashion week was the first week of February, you can see the designers fashions at this link. There are 5 designers, but 2 of them are decoys. Fashion week occurred before the final competitions so to prevent any spoilers, the 5 contestants who were still in the running were there. We know that Sweet P was eliminated, and only 1 of either Chris or Rami is actually competing. Anyway, the final show will be this Wednesday on Bravo TV at 8:00 PM. Watch and enjoy.
Then starting in March, is the Runway clone “Top Chef”. This show uses the same format only with a dozen or so chefs competing each week.







